
Russia· Sergei LavrovUS Withdrawal from Iraq and Iran's Regional Influence
Discussions are ongoing regarding the US withdrawal from Iraq, with differing views on whether it's a strategic mistake allowing Iran to retain influence or a result of resistance.
Background
The United States has maintained a military presence in Iraq since 2003. This presence is often viewed in the context of regional power dynamics, particularly concerning Iran's influence in Iraq and the broader Middle East. The relationship between the US and Iran has been marked by long-standing tensions and sanctions.
Quorum · collective opinions
US Troop Withdrawal and Iraq's Security Transition
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoGeobits report on the departure of the last US and UK troops from Iraq, signifying the end of the coalition mission.
Concerns are raised about the strategic risk of the withdrawal, particularly the potential for Iranian-aligned militias to strengthen their position within Iraq's political and security systems.
Iraq is reported to be initiating a new phase to strengthen state control, including disarming foreign groups and integrating PMF.
One geobit criticizes the financial cost of the Iraq war, labeling it an 'illegal war and genocide' with trillions of dollars spent.
Geobits discuss how American media allegedly manipulated public opinion to support the war in Iraq, drawing parallels with coverage of Gaza.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Iran's Enduring Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoDespite the US withdrawal, Iran is seen as maintaining significant influence in Iraq, as evidenced by agreements on flight operations and ongoing economic ties.
The US's past interventions in Iraq are criticized, with some viewing the withdrawal as a defeat for Washington.
Iraq Raises Alarm on Terror Threat from Syria Post-US Withdrawal
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoIraq warns of ISIS fighters entering from Syria, a day after US troops left, raising concerns about regional security.
US withdrawal from Iraq and Iran's regional influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe US withdrawal from Iraq is seen as a defeat for Washington, while Iran's continued presence and growing influence in Iraq are noted.
Iraq expresses readiness to mediate between the US and Iran, emphasizing the need for diplomatic channels to prevent further conflict and ensure regional stability.
Skepticism is expressed regarding past justifications for the Iraq War, drawing parallels to current geopolitical narratives.
A general sentiment of hope for Iraq to maintain its sovereignty and control over its country.
US Troop Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Stability
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoMany express relief and support for the US withdrawal, viewing it as a positive step for Iraq's sovereignty and an end to a controversial military presence.
Some criticize past US interventions in Iraq, drawing parallels to historical events and questioning the justifications for military actions.
Concern is raised for veterans who suffered health consequences due to their service in Iraq and Afghanistan.
US Troop Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe withdrawal of US troops from Iraq is noted as a significant event, with Moscow welcoming it and analysis focusing on the shifting regional power dynamics and Iran's influence.
Humanitarian organizations urge Iraqi authorities to ensure due process rights for over 5,700 detainees transferred from north-east Syria.
Iraq's Post-US Withdrawal Geopolitical Landscape
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe departure of US forces from Iraq marks a new phase, with Moscow welcoming the withdrawal and Iraq's place in the US-Iranian rivalry being reshaped.
The 2003 Iraq War is widely criticized as illegal and driven by false pretenses, with media figures who supported it facing scrutiny for their lack of apologies.
Iraqi authorities are urged to ensure full due process rights and urgent protection for child rights for over 5,700 detainees transferred from north-east Syria.
Historical analyses and book reviews offer insights into Iraq's social classes, revolutionary movements, and past events like the search for WMDs.
Iraq's Post-US Troop Withdrawal Landscape and Regional Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoMoscow welcomes the withdrawal of US and allied troops from Iraq, and some geobits celebrate the departure of the international coalition.
Analysts note that while US forces have left, Iran retains substantial influence in Iraq, redefining the country's role in the US-Iranian rivalry.
Several posts reflect on the 2003 Iraq War, its justifications, and the role of media and politicians in promoting it, drawing parallels to current events.
Iraq's Political Situation and US Troop Withdrawal
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThere is celebration over the departure of international coalition and US troops from Iraq, with some viewing it as a significant development.
Concerns are raised about the continued presence and influence of Iran-backed militias in Iraq after the US withdrawal.
Iraq is noted for submitting films for the Academy Awards.
US Troop Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Stability
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe withdrawal prompts reflections on the 2003 Iraq invasion and the role of media figures who supported it.
Iraq is celebrating the departure of international coalition and US troops, viewing it as a positive development for national sovereignty.
Concerns are raised about the continued presence and influence of Iran-backed militias in Iraq following the US withdrawal.
Iraq War: Historical Context and US Withdrawal Discussions
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoCommentators are critical of the US intervention in Iraq, suggesting it was based on misinformation and had far-reaching negative consequences.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Implications
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe US withdrawal prompts criticism of the Iraq War, its origins based on false WMD claims, and its long-term consequences, including mass migration and the rise of ultra-right parties.
The withdrawal highlights Iraq's delicate position between the US and Iran, with concerns about Tehran's armed allies and the challenge of disarming groups in Iraq.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoMany view the US withdrawal as a 'massive strategic and tactical mistake' that leaves Iraq vulnerable and strengthens Iran's regional influence.
There is continued criticism of the initial invasion and prolonged presence in Iraq, with some calling it a 'war crime' and accusing the US of 'stealing money'.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoMany view the US withdrawal from Iraq as a 'massive strategic and tactical mistake' that could allow Iran to increase its influence in the region.
The withdrawal is seen by some as a restoration of Iraq's national sovereignty and a positive step towards strengthening its independence.
Skepticism is expressed regarding claims of quick war resolutions, drawing parallels to the prolonged Iraq war despite initial promises.
Iraq's Post-US Withdrawal Future and Reconstruction Efforts
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoAnalysts express worry that Iran might fill the power vacuum left by the US withdrawal, impacting Iraq's sovereignty and regional stability.
Discussions continue regarding Iraq's reconstruction, the plight of internally displaced people, and issues of religious freedom for Yazidis.
The Iraq war is criticized as a mistake, with comparisons drawn to other unpopular political decisions and questioning its rationale.
Turkiye's Role in Iraqi Kurdistan After US Withdrawal
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoWith the US withdrawal, Turkiye is expected to increase its influence in Iraqi Kurdistan, while many analysts worry about Iran filling the power vacuum.
Iraq War Legacy and US Withdrawal
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThere is criticism of the US intervention in Iraq, its handling of post-war rebuilding, and the strategic implications of its withdrawal, including increased Iranian influence.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Regional Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe US withdrawal from Iraq is seen by some as a 'massive strategic and tactical mistake' that enables Iran to maintain its influence in the region.
The withdrawal is attributed to a long history of resistance against US forces and public opposition to American interference, with military deterrence deemed necessary to protect this achievement.
Reflections on the Iraq War highlight its human and financial costs, as well as the failures in rebuilding efforts that created a vacuum for groups like ISIS.
Iraq Warns of ISIS Fighters Crossing from Syria After US Withdrawal
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoGeobits report Iraq's alarm over the terror threat posed by ISIS fighters potentially crossing from Syria after the US withdrawal.
US Withdrawal from Iraq and Iranian Influence
First report 5d agoLast update 5d agoThe US withdrawal is criticized as a massive strategic and tactical mistake that has allowed Iran to increase its influence in Iraq.
Public figures · stances & shifts
Sergei Lavrov
Minister of Foreign Affairs · Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs · Russia
on Russia's assessment of US withdrawal from Iraq
Supports Russia's assessment of US withdrawal from Iraq: Posts in this cluster support Russia's assessment of US withdrawal from Iraq (mean stance +0.94).
iWitness comments
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.