The proposal for an antisemitism taskforce is seen as a necessary measure to combat antisemitism, with some noting that testimonies of violence and harassment against Jewish people are often ignored.

Critics argue that the proposed taskforce is a result of foreign interference and Zionist political movements, aiming to control Australian institutions and suppress criticism of Israel.

There are concerns that the taskforce could be used to stifle free speech and legitimate criticism of Israel, creating a climate where certain discussions are deemed a threat to the nation.